As some of you know, I was home schooled as a child, all the way up to my freshman year of high school. I've been thinking a lot about the whole idea of home schooling lately, and I saw this news bit last week about how more and more people are choosing home school as an alternative to our abysmal public school system (particularly here in California).
One of the biggest concerns many have with this trend, I think, is the potential negative impact that it may have on the poor. Obviously, one can't be home schooled if there isn't anyone at home to be the teacher, so low income, single parent households would find it hard or impossible to home school a child. The problem is that in many cases, children that are taught in a home school environment actually tend to do better in college than those that attended public or private schools. So some say that it "looks good" on a college application if one was home schooled. Where does that leave the already disadvantaged inner city students?
Even more importantly, it doesn't seem that this trend is helping public schools, especially in the area of funding. Instead of trying to make public schools better, many perceive that parents that choose home school for their children are effectively "jumping ship," turning a blind eye to the very serious problem of public education in our country, dismissing it as "someone else's problem."
On a personal note, I'm very glad that I was home schooled, especially during my early, formative years. I went into high school with a very solid idea of my beliefs and values, and who I was and was not. I also excelled in public high school, and whether that was due to my home schooling or simply to a genetic or spiritual disposition is up for debate, but I can't help but think that home school had a lot to do with it.
I was taught to be very self-motivated, and many of my studies, especially in middle school, were greatly self-directed. This value of self-motivation is one that I hear many home schooled students talk about, and it also felt to me that it was somewhat lacking from the general public student body. I know that I got a lot more out of my years of college because of the fact that I had learned the value and joy of learning.
So what's the verdict? Personally, I think that home schooling, along with plenty of social peer interaction and extracurricular activities, is the ideal. But the reality is that we simply cannot abandon public schools, leaving them only for those who can't afford private school, or who don't have the resources or time for home school. All I know is that I have a lot of thinking to do if I am ever blessed with children. In the meantime, I think it is my duty to do what I can to help better our public schools.
Any thoughts?
Peace out.